Craig and Rodriguez, who placed third in Love Island USA 's season 6, recently broke up on July 27, a source told PEOPLE. Shortly afterwards, their drama publicly escalated in a series of Instagram statements, with Craig ultimately calling Rodriguez a "manipulative liar."

Craig said the theories she has seen online surrounding their breakup don't match up to "how terrible, disgusting and disappointing" the situation is.

"I want to close this chapter of my life. Like, I don’t want it to take any more of my energy," she said of the breakup with her co-star.