After 40 years of The Goonies and no sequel, fans and the original cast alike aren’t sure whether a reboot would be possible. But that doesn’t mean the stars aren’t hopeful to reprise their popular roles once more.

Josh Brolin is weighing in on whether or not he thinks a Goonies sequel is a good idea 40 years after the film’s original release. Brolin, 57, admitted that he had some “trepidation” about a second movie while speaking with Entertainment Tonight on July 31.